Jenna Ortega has quickly established herself as a rising star in the horror genre, captivating audiences with her intense performances and ability to bring depth to her roles. From her early days in the industry to her more recent, highly praised performances, Ortega’s diverse selection of horror movies showcases her versatility. Here, we rank every Jenna Ortega horror movie from worst to best, offering insights into her roles and the films that helped cement her as one of the genre’s most talented stars.
1. The Babysitter: Killer Queen (2020)
Overview: In The Babysitter: Killer Queen, Jenna Ortega plays a supporting role in this over-the-top, horror-comedy sequel. While the film boasts an ensemble cast and tries to channel a mix of campy fun with gruesome kills, it doesn’t quite capture the magic of its predecessor.
Why It’s Ranked Here:
- The film’s reliance on exaggerated humor and horror clichés doesn’t quite land for some viewers.
- Jenna Ortega’s character is enjoyable but doesn’t have enough screen time to make a lasting impact.
What We Loved:
- The quirky, fun atmosphere.
- Ortega’s comedic timing in her role as a more grounded character compared to the chaos around her.
2. X (2022)
Overview: In X, a slasher film directed by Ti West, Jenna Ortega takes on a pivotal role in a group of young adults shooting an adult film in 1970s Texas. The situation quickly turns deadly when they encounter a mysterious and dangerous elderly couple. Ortega plays Lorraine, an inexperienced and morally conflicted character caught in the middle of the horror.
Why It’s Ranked Here:
- While the movie has an engaging storyline and some compelling performances, Ortega’s role feels more subdued compared to other standout characters in the film.
- X is more about the horrors of the adult industry and the ensuing chaos than any one character’s journey, limiting Ortega’s presence.
What We Loved:
- The retro vibe and ’70s aesthetic.
- The moments Ortega shares on screen, filled with tension and uncertainty.
3. Scream (2022)
Overview: Scream (2022) is a revitalization of the iconic slasher franchise, and Jenna Ortega plays Tara Carpenter, the film’s opening victim. While her character doesn’t last long, Ortega’s gripping performance sets the tone for the entire movie, showing her range even in a small but impactful role.
Why It’s Ranked Here:
- While her role is brief, Ortega makes the most of her screen time, delivering a memorable and suspenseful moment.
- The movie’s mix of legacy characters and new faces offers a fresh take, but Ortega’s character’s fate serves as a shock to the audience, proving her capacity to captivate with minimal screen presence.
What We Loved:
- Ortega’s standout opening sequence, which injects fresh energy into the Scream franchise.
- The overall suspense and intensity of the movie.
4. Studio 666 (2022)
Overview: In Studio 666, Jenna Ortega stars alongside rock legends Foo Fighters in this horror-comedy about a band recording an album in a haunted mansion. Ortega plays a pivotal role as a member of the band’s team caught up in the supernatural events unfolding.
Why It’s Ranked Here:
- While the film plays more on comedy than genuine horror, Ortega’s charm shines through in a somewhat chaotic plot.
- The unique blend of real-life rockstars and horror makes it a fun watch, though the execution is hit-or-miss.
What We Loved:
- Ortega’s natural chemistry with the cast.
- The fun, energetic vibe that keeps the film lively.
5. Scream VI (2023)
Overview: Returning as Tara Carpenter in Scream VI, Ortega’s character takes a more central role in this installment, moving the franchise to New York City. Tara’s resilience and development are key to the story, as she is once again targeted by the masked killer, Ghostface.
Why It’s Ranked Here:
- This movie marks a shift in Tara’s character arc, giving Ortega more room to showcase her growth from a terrified victim to a more empowered survivor.
- Ortega’s nuanced performance elevates the stakes, making her one of the most compelling characters in the series.
What We Loved:
- The New York City setting, which breathes new life into the Scream franchise.
- Ortega’s standout moments that show her adaptability in taking on a larger role.
6. X: Pearl (2022)
Overview: Though Ortega’s role in Pearl is smaller compared to X, the film is a prequel that delves deeper into the backstory of Pearl (played by Mia Goth). Jenna Ortega’s cameo adds a subtle yet impactful layer to the movie, offering a quiet but significant contribution to the film’s chilling atmosphere.
Why It’s Ranked Here:
- Ortega’s role is brief, but her performance contrasts well with the eerie, slow-burn horror of Pearl.
- While not a central figure, Ortega’s involvement in the storyline adds depth to the overall narrative.
What We Loved:
- The stunning, artistic direction of the film.
- Ortega’s ability to convey depth in a limited role.
7. The Fallout (2021)
Overview: Not traditionally a horror movie, The Fallout still has elements of psychological thriller that showcase Ortega’s range. The film focuses on a school shooting’s aftermath and the emotional toll it takes on its survivors. Ortega plays Vada, a teenage girl struggling to find herself in the wake of trauma.
Why It’s Ranked Here:
- While not strictly a horror film, Ortega’s portrayal of trauma and grief is hauntingly powerful.
- The film is a character-driven piece, and Ortega’s performance is the heart of the film.
What We Loved:
- Ortega’s ability to take on a complex and deeply emotional role.
- The film’s raw and heartfelt depiction of grief.
8. Wednesday (2022)
Overview: Although Wednesday is a series rather than a film, it deserves a spot on this list. Ortega stars as the iconic Wednesday Addams in this supernatural thriller, blending dark comedy with mystery as the young teen navigates her time at Nevermore Academy. Ortega brings a fresh, compelling energy to the role, perfectly balancing Wednesday’s macabre charm and emotional depth.
Why It’s Ranked Here:
- Ortega’s performance truly shines in this iconic role, giving the character a new depth while still honoring the spirit of the original.
- The show’s blend of mystery and horror with Ortega’s exceptional performance makes this one of her best horror-related roles.
What We Loved:
- Ortega’s perfect embodiment of Wednesday’s dark, sarcastic nature.
- The series’ mix of horror, humor, and mystery.
Ranking Table:
| Rank | Movie Title | Role | Key Highlight |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Wednesday (2022) | Wednesday Addams | Perfectly captures Wednesday’s dark charm |
| 2 | Scream VI (2023) | Tara Carpenter | From victim to survivor, Ortega owns the role |
| 3 | The Fallout (2021) | Vada | Gripping emotional depth in a non-horror role |
| 4 | Scream (2022) | Tara Carpenter | Iconic opening sequence with memorable moments |
| 5 | X: Pearl (2022) | Supporting Role | Subtle, impactful performance in a chilling film |
| 6 | Studio 666 (2022) | Team Member | Fun, energetic role with great chemistry |
| 7 | X (2022) | Lorraine | Strong performance in a compelling slasher film |
| 8 | The Babysitter: Killer Queen (2020) | Supporting Role | Lively character but lacks enough screen time |
Conclusion:
Jenna Ortega has firmly established herself as a force to be reckoned with in the horror genre, thanks to her ability to blend depth with chilling performances. From Scream to Wednesday, each film on this list showcases her versatility and commitment to the craft. Whether she’s facing a masked killer or navigating psychological trauma, Ortega has proven she can handle it all with grace and intensity.
Click here to learn more
